« THE LONG HAUL | Main | NEW DAY DAWNS »

HELLO WORLD! GOODBYE MILWAUKEE!

I was reminded yesterday by the features editor of the Milwaukee Journal-Sentinel, Jill Williams, that I hadn't been in the newsroom for a long time. I didn't realize how times change; tastes change; and the Milwaukee Journal-Sentinel was a place of excellence -- where the readers' needs come first.

But I have been a reporter longer than Jill. And you don't have to be Bob Woodward to know that whenever someone says that a decision is not personal, but "business," that person means one of two things: It is indeed personal or it's just plain vindictive.

Jill Williams, who did not like my column, was telling me this as she fired me.

She was explaining that my column, which has run in the Milwaukee Journal-Sentinel for 21 years -- would no longer be there.

It WILL still run in other newspapers, including the (other and dearer) one where I began my career, The Capital Times in Madison. It will be archived on this site, where you can read it, also.

But it won't be in the newspaper where my column became well-known - where I wrote when my husband died, when my first child was born, when I wrote my first novel.

Of course, sentiment has no place in a newsroom. I agree with my ex-editor on that. And I haven't kept up with the needs of the readers.

Actually, Jill wasn't going to tell me this personally.

She wrote that e-mail to me, pointing out how I no longer understood the dynamics of a fast-paced and ever-changing newsroom (ever-changing in part because no one gets news from newspapers anymore) because I found out from a reader that I'd been axed.

In a form letter sent me by a reader who assumed this was MY choice and wrote to try to dissuade me, my direct editor said, "The SYNDICATED columnist Jacquelyn Mitchard will no longer be featured..." as if a big wind had come along and blown me away.

When I wrote a note to Jill, said that she naturally assumed that Tribune Media (which has distributed my column for ten years, as well as the writings of hundreds of other writers) would tell me.

She thought it was really Tribune Media's job to to inform me personally.

And of my hope that I might say goodbye to people with whom I've had a conversation every Sunday morning for 21 years ... well, Jill basically said he would forward my vexatious letter to the BIG BOSSES, as if I should fear them now. There's a tradition at The Milwaukee Journal Sentinel called "the long crawl." It's the position a reporter assumes when he or she has left and wants to be for a job when things go bad out there. A good friend did that some years ago. She did get a job -- and constant, utter disrespect and humiliation along with her paycheck.

I'd rather not.

In fact, I'd rather be a mail carrier.

Back to Jill.

She didn't really think the syndicate would tell me.

She just didn't want to.

She has "put me on waivers" before -- pointing out to me that my column should NOT be political, and just always have more heart and soul than brains; it should include some humor (but not too much) and be useful every day to the citizens of Milwaukee.

And, you know, it hasn't always been a great column.

Sometimes, it's only been a good column, and once in a while a real dumb column. An old friend of mine once said that about writing and baseball that getting a hit three of five times at bat was a good average; and I've maintained that average. But I haven't done it well enough to meet the standards of The Milwaukee Journal-Sentinel. When I was a reporter there, I was often told I wasn't among those who were the pride of a newspaper known for its sparkling writing, its incisive reporting and its glorious tradition of beautiful presentation and multitudes of national awards.

Because of personal reasons, I left to become a speechwriter for Donna Shalala, then a magazine journalist, then an author.

I won awards, got on the New York Times bestseller list; but I never cracked the ranks of the top reporters in Milwaukee. Though many former friends (and some who still are my friends) work there and love it, others simply learned that, after working at the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel, there nothing else higher to which they could aspire.

However, it was not losing the account that bothered me.

It will hurt my heart, although not my wallet, not to be featured in the newspaper whose readers I loved.

What wounds me was not being able to say goodbye.

Through that column, I've met good acquaintances and dear friends. I received 300 letters the day after I wrote about my husband's death, and 200 more the next day. Some of them were from readers who never agreed with a word I said. I answered every one personally.

It seems to me ungentle and discourteous to try to slide an individual -- despite how little esteem one might feel for that person -- under a rug, hoping no one will notice.

But that was always the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel way.

Years ago, when the Journal and Sentinel merged. a random hit list of reporters were eliminated. Some were so-so; some were excellent writers whose minds the paper simply couldn't control. They were given moments to pack a few cardboard boxes and escorted to the elevators by security guards, while their colleagues watched in silence. It was a sort of Joe McCarthy thing, the key word here being "silence."

No one dared speak for fear the ax would fall next on him, on her.

I was long-gone by then.

But twenty years ago, when I still worked there full-time, I was told that the newspaper's generous maternity leave would not apply to me because my newborn son was adopted, not... well, "real." However, the woman who had to tell me that soon quit her management job, because she found doing such things repugnant. She lost money and status, but gained tremendous respect.

I guess I did need a kick in the pants.

I'm steaming now; but I'll cool off.

My essays have been anthologized in twelve books over the past two years.

So I won't be silent. I'll still be in other newspapers, from Iowa to Maryland, will write novels for adults and teens and picture books for kids, and continue as an editor for Wondertime magazine and an occasional contributor to Parade magazine.

But if you're a reader who had your Sunday-morning coffee with me for all those years, and you see this, please listen.

I care for you more than you know, more than you'll ever know. In my time of shadow, you sustained me. In my time of harvest, you celebrated with me. I will never forget you; and I hope you will never forget me.

All things have a natural place of ending; and their ending does not invalidate their worth.

So,'bye Milwaukee.

No one writer is ever as important as a newspaper, and despite my chagrin at my impolitely engineered demise, I know you'll continue to rely on wonderful writers such as Whitney Gould and Tim Cuprisin and Joanne Weintraub, Gita Sharma Jensen and others.

The truly great columnist Molly Ivins died yesterday of breast cancer. And though I'm not fixin' to die for a long time coming, my last word in the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel would have been to pay tribute to a writer who never used a Derringer to fire off a shot when a Colts Dragoon would do.

We should all learn a lesson from Molly and say what we mean without fear, before it's too late.

In the time I have left, I hope to write some things that provoke, some things that make people laugh and cry -- to go on, as I wrote in my first column, to do the verbal equivalent of singing and dancing.

It will just be on other stages.

with love,

Jackie M.

Comments (11)

Anne:

Jackie -

I'm so sorry.

I know how this stings. I know because I've been hurt in circumstances very similar. I can still recall the date (June 16) of one such day of hurt. No matter the accomplishments and medals of honor we rack up despite the Jills of this world, it hurts and it always will.

I know you as a writer. A good one. You will channel this real hurt and real affront on "another stage." When you do, it will be a damn good novel, and Jill will still be a features editor.

Your feelings are just. Just use them.

Moira:

I met you years ago at a Juvenie Diabetes Foundation event in Madison. I've also read your column in the Journal Sentinel since I was in high school. We will miss you. I'm sure that I speak for many when I say thank you for many years of wonderful columns. We'll keep reading, even if we can't do it in the morning paper.

Elena:

Hu Jackie,
I am so sorry. Please know that I love your essays. I have been reading your essays from the JS website for 6 years. I will get rid of the JS from my favorites and find you somewhere else. I really hate when people are such cowards.
--Elena

Carol:

As is often the case, those who make decisions do not have the faintest idea of what is on the minds and in the hearts of those it will effect.

For those of us in the Milwaukee area who have been with you from the start, this is a most unpleasant turn of events and yet, as you said, not all that surprising.

The decision of your ex-editor simply reaffirms my status as a pawn in the world of commerce. She did not make any effort to get feedback from those of us who indeed did have their morning coffee with you every Sunday morning.

I had the initial reaction of "How dare she assume what is and is not enjoyable, acceptable, or even (gasp) marketable to us".

Would it have been so very difficult to do a benign survey to see what we "readers" prefer? Couldn't she have said that the Journal-Sentinel was considering revamping its Lifestyle section and valued the opinions of the readers of that section? Couldn't we have had a voice, stating what we did and did not like in that section? Had she done that, she would have gotten a result she obviously did not want, one that would have contradicted her already-made-up mind.

As always, we remain (in the eyes of your ex-editor) nameless, faceless non-entities. She will decide for us. I started sharing my Sunday mornings with you when I was in my twenties. Your column entertained me, made me laugh, made me cry, and became a friend to me, albeit not in the traditional sense.

The arrogance of the Journal-Sentinel to not even let you say good-bye does not surprise me. Just as you mentioned, when the papers merged many an excellent writer was shuffled out the door to the detriment of the readers.

I have seen many decisions made over the years by numerous companies (without the input of their customers) that eventually blew up in their faces. I suspect this is one of them.

Barbara:

Oh, Sunday will not be the same without you Jackie Michard!
I have laughed, cried, grieved and admired you through the years.
Your life has been an open honest dialog, I am always wanting the best for you and your family.
Too bad for Milwaukee readers.

MARIA:

I would just like to let you know I have searched for weeks now for your column in the Journal and finally saw the "News" on TV last night that you really had been cut. I guess I was in denial that they would actually cut such a good column.
I am dropping my Journal subscription when it runs out, which is soon. It's the last straw with that paper. I will continue to read your column on line. And yes, I used to have coffee with you on Sun. mornings....Thank You.

Hello Jackie,

Until seeing the Channel 12 promos and reading this, my family and I could not figure out where your column disappeared to. I am glad to know you are well, but unhappy that you were treated so poorly. Our Sunday mornings always feature a hearty breakfast and spirited discussion about interesting pieces we've read in the paper. You were always a topic of discussion. Now, you will continue to be...after I bookmark your site!

Just want to wish you well on all your projects. I wrote a book some time back and your email reply gave me inspiration along with great advice. I am still looking for a publisher, but that, too, will happen when it's right. Thanks!
Jeff Reindl

I AM VERY SADDENDED THAT JACKIE MITCHARD WAS SO UNCEREMONIUSLY "DUMPED" FROM THE MILWAUKEE JOURNAL/SENTINEL.
I GUESS UPPER MANAGEMENT IS ALL THE SAME--PUSH THE DIRTY WORK OFF ON SOMEONE ELSE!
WELL JACKIE, I, FOR ONE, WILL MISS YOUR COLUMN TREMENDOUSLY. I TRULY DID LOOK FORWARD TO IT EVERY SUNDAY & THE "LIFESTYLE" SECTION WILL NEVER BE THE SAME. I KNOW THAT WHEREVER YOUR COLUMN SHOWS UP NEXT WILL BE ONE LUCKY PUBLICATION TO HAVE YOU.
THE MJS HAS REALLY PULLED A BONER THIS TIME, BUT I WISH YOU ALL THE BEST IN ALL THAT YOU DO--IN YOUR WORK & YOUR LIFE. AND I WILL CONTINUE TO VISIT YOUR WEBSITE TO KEEP UP WITH YOUR NEWS. GOOD LUCK & GOD BLESS!! DIANE

Bill Kurtz:

An additional thought to follow up the e-mail I sent you the other day. Being an independent writer, not at the mercies of the Journal Sentinel or any other paper, your situation reminds me of something Pete Hammill wrote 25 years ago that I'll never forget. Hammill wrote that he had been amazed that Barry Goldwater twice said something he totally agreed with, and contacted a friend of Goldwater to ask what was going on.
"Barry seems to have decided," the friend said, "that he's at a point in life where he has nothing left to lose, and is free to say what he honestly believes."
That's a great position to be in. Again, God bless you.
Bill Kurtz
wkurtz@carthage.edu

Betty Majeski:

I'm confused by your comments in the very first paragraph: "the Milwaukee Journal-Sentinel was a place of excellence---where the readers' needs come first." Balderdash!!! You would still have a column w/JS if that were true!! How I miss you, but certainly don't miss the JS!!

Thank you for all the days you made brighter for me.

Catherine Fredericks:

Dear Jacquelyn, I don't know if you will ever get this but years ago you wrote an article about your friends father Mr. Neilon, this Irishman was not a happy soul. I had it for years and years and every St.Patrick's day made copies to put into St. Pats cards. I must have put it in a new safe place because I cant find it. Is there any way that I can get a copy. Thank you so much. Catherine Fredericks

Post a comment

(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)

About

This page contains a single entry from the blog posted on February 1, 2007 6:18 AM.

The previous post in this blog was THE LONG HAUL.

The next post in this blog is NEW DAY DAWNS.

Many more can be found on the main index page or by looking through the archives.

Powered by
Movable Type 3.35